Posted by: portersprospectreport | September 27, 2008

2008 Bowman Chrome Addendum


Hello to all of you!  I apologize for my lengthy absense from the blog.  I have been living in a prolonged technological nightmare with my laptop at the epicenter.  When Dell offers a 2 year warrantee, they really should have stated that it was a life span.  Over the past 2 weeks, my battery, ac adapter and hard drive died.  My replacement drive then died and my replacement to the replacement was misinstalled by the tech “gurus” at a local store.

Excuses aside, I am back with an addendum to my article that Beckett graciously published in the October Baseball Monthly.  Beckett’s Eric Jahnke was great to work with and is a good friend in the industry.  He served as the interim editor of this month’s publication and worked dilligently to make my article and Brian Fleisher’s Bowman Chrome article fit nicely in the magazine.

Due to my longwindedness (who me?) a great deal of the most important sleeper prospect analysis was omitted.  Here is the article in its full text as it was submitted to Beckett a month ago.


08 Bowman Chrome Prospect Analysis

The mid-summer release of Bowman Chrome has consistently struck gold with signatures and base cards of baseball’s elite young prospects.  In 2006, Alex Gordon, Cameron Maybin, and Prince Fielder’s highly sought after autographs were complimented nicely by first time base cards of Mat Gamel, Jose Tabata, Elvis Andrus, and Jeremy Hellickson.  2007’s set boasted autos of Joba Chamberlain, Tim Lincecum, and Fernando Martinez, while base cards of Johnny Cueto, Chris Carter, Brett Anderson, and Tommy Hanson have provided solid depth to the set. 


The 2008 set has, in large part, stayed true to the successful formula of years past with, first year autographs of top prospects, a 110 card first year prospect list, various pretty-colored serial numbered refractors and 1/1 printing plates.  Also returning to the set, is the Head of the Class dual autograph subset which boasts first rate pairings of Yankees Joba Chamberlain and Phil Hughes, Tampa Bay Rays David Price and Evan Longoria, and Prince Fielder and Matt LaPorta.


As Bowman hits the shelves, a new array of prospects awaits to become household names amongst the collecting masses.  Autographs of elite prospects like Lars Anderson, Austin Jackson, Angel Villalona, Ryan Kalish, and Engel Beltre headline the set while first year prospect cards of Dominic Brown, Juan Francisco, Jake Arrieta, and Jhoulys Chacin have collectors flooding the Ebay search engine.


This article will give a closer look at some of the 1st year autographed and non-autographed prospect cards that are currently overshadowed by the much-hyped list mentioned above.  All prices have been determined by average Ebay sales finished between 8/16 and 8/31.




Matt Latos—San Diego Padres RHP  H/W: 6’5” 210 lb.   B/T: R/R  DOB: 12/9/87



Latos was passed over by teams until the 11th round in the 2006 draft due to concerns about his maturity and exuberant bonus demands.  Latos agreed to a way overslot $1.25 million bonus just moments before the deadline and reported to short season Low-A Eugene for 16 games where he went 1-3 with a 3.83 ERA and 74 K’s in 56 IP.  Latos has spent this season at three different stops, including Eugene, where he has a cumulative 2-3 record with a 2.65 ERA and 60 K’s in just 51 IP.  Opponents are hitting just .223 against him and he forces 1.5 groundouts per flyout.


Ebay Market Price: $7.50-10.00


Strengths:  Latos has the makings of three very good MLB quality pitches including a fastball that reaches 94-97 MPH.  Because of his long frame, Latos is able to get good downhill leverage on the ball with late movement.  Complimenting his fastball are a tight curveball and hard change with a late drop that could develop into an out pitch.  His long lean frame suggests that he could build more bulk as he matures.  In addition, Latos is a good competitor who wants to win.


Weaknesses: An oblique injury in late May sidelined Matt for a couple of months, limiting him to only 14 games this season.  While the injury seems to not have any long term effects, injuries to young prospects, especially pitchers, are never a good thing. Latos needs to get a better feel for his curve and change.  Like many young power pitchers, he tends to overthrow them and needs to learn how to take a little off of the pitches in order to give them more action.


Bottom Line:  Latos has the stuff and stature to be a front of the rotation pitcher in the next three to four seasons.  If he can get a full healthy season under his belt next year, Latos could very well put up some dominant numbers and place himself on the fast track to Petco Park.




Michael Watt—L.A. Dodgers LHP   H/W: 6’1” 185 lb.   B/T: L/L   DOB: 2/24/89




Watt was a 2nd round pick by the Dodgers in the 2007 draft out of high school in California.  Watt features an 89-92 MPH fastball with good movement and a developing curveball.  Some were skeptical of Watt’s acquisition as a 2nd rounder, but he has responded well at rookie-level Ogden where he has gone 8-4 with a 4.34 ERA and 74 K’s in 75 IP.


Ebay Per Card Market Price: $6.00-8.00


Positives: Watt has proven to be durable, averaging 6 IP per start and he has won 8 of his last 10 decisions.  Unlike many young southpaws, Watt has displayed good control of his sinking fastball and has a very good 1.79 ground out to flyout ratio.  Watt’s control is improving after some early season struggles, which means that he may be becoming more consistent with his breaking ball.


Negatives: Watt has some mechanical issues to iron out and his slight 6-1 185 lb. frame indicates that he has likely topped out physically and will not add velocity.  Refining his off-speed pitches will continue to be paramount to his development as a mid-rotation pitcher. Rookie-Level hitters are batting .270 against him this season, which indicates that Watt pitches to contact or does not have dominant enough stuff to exploit younger hitters.  Either way, this could become an issue as he faces better hitters.


Bottom Line: The Dodgers have a knack for scouting and developing young pitching talent, and Watt has progressed well so far.  Watt does not have frontline stuff, but he could very well be a nice mid-rotation compliment to future ace Clayton Kershaw.




John Jaso—Tampa Bay Rays C     H/W: 6’2” 205 lb.    B/T: L/R     DOB: 9/19/83

Jaso is the oldest prospect on this list being drafted by the Rays in 2003 out of Southwestern.  Jaso has been a .300 career hitter through 5 minor league seasons averaging 8 HR and 45 RBI per season.  This year, Jaso performed well at AA Montgomery and AAA Durham hitting .273 with 12 HR 67 RBI and a sterling 72 walks to only 47 K’s. 


Ebay Market Price: $5.00-7.50


Strengths: The impeccable walk to strikeout ratio stands out first, as Jaso has a strong grasp of the strike zone and a quick but unorthodox swing that generates power to the gaps.  Jaso is also has solid catching skills and is agile for a player of his size. 


Weaknesses: Jaso will turn 25 by the time you read this issue, which is not young for a prospect.  He has had a history of health issues, including shoulder ailments which limit his arm strength and put into doubt his ability to stay behind the plate long term.


Bottom Line: Jaso has enough upside to push Dioner Navarro for time behind the plate in Tampa Bay.  Jaso was just called up on September 1st when the rosters were expanded. With the Rays as a playoff contender, Jaso may get a look behind the plate, and his lefthanded bat may make a dent in some box scores down the stretch.  His ceiling is not nearly as high as other players on this list, but he is currently the player on this list who is most likely to make an immediate impact with his club.





Jose Vallejo—Texas Rangers 2B     H/W: 6’0” 172lb.    B:S T:R     DOB: 9/11/86

Vallejo was signed by the Rangers as a free agent from the Dominican Republic in 2004.  Scouted mainly for his infield defense and blazing speed, Vallejo’s power and plate discipline hindered him from being one of Texas’ top prospects in 2007.  This season has been a different story as Vallejo has combined to hit .295 with 11 HR 81 RBI and 80 Runs in 133 games between High-A Bakersfield and AA Frisco.  He also continues to torch opposing batteries on the basepaths, stealing 40 bases in 44 attempts. 


Ebay Per Card Market Price: $0.30-0.50


Positives: Vallejo has had a tremendous breakout this season.  His 11 HR in 533 AB’s more than doubled the 5 that he had accrued in over 1,300 career AB’s.  While increasing his power production, Vallejo has also cut down his strikeouts from last season.  At just 21 years old he has adjusted quite well to AA baseball and is shaping up to be a fine top of the order candidate who should make his MLB debut within the next two seasons.


Negatives: Ian Kinsler.  The All-Star 2B is locked up with the Rangers through 2013 with little chance of parole.  Vallejo has the athleticism and arm strength to make a transition to CF or LF, but the presence of other viable options like John Mayberry Jr., Julio Borbon, Nelson Cruz, and eventually Engel Beltre provide considerable competition for Vallejo.  Additionally, this season’s success in hitter-friendly leagues like the California League and Texas League may be a factor in the spike in Vallejo’s plate production.


Bottom Line: Vallejo’s most pertinent value may be as a trading chip that the Rangers could employ to attain some much needed pitching help.  Whether he is in a Rangers uniform or not, Jose Vallejo’s boost in offensive production is cause to take notice and, at less than a half dollar per card, his chrome prospect cards are solid values.



Jose Martinez—Chicago White Sox OF   H/W: 6’5”  170 lb.  B:R T:R  DOB 7/25/88


Signed out of Venezuela in 2006, Jose Martinez opened some eyes last year at Rookie Level Bristol hitting .282 with 7 HR 37 RBI and 12 SB in 65 games.  Ranked as the 7th rated prospect by Baseball America, Martinez earned a promotion to Low-A Kannapolis and continued to show promise hitting .306 with 2 HR 17 RBI and 7 SB in 39 games. In mid-May, Martinez suffered a torn ACL which sidelined him for the rest of the ’08 season. 


Ebay Market Price: $0.75-1.00


Positives:  Martinez has a long lean frame that should add strength as it matures.  Martinez boasts a raw 5 tool skill set with plus plus power potential and good speed.  He has the range and arm strength to play any OF position and his plate discipline is promising for a prospect of his age.


Negatives: With any knee injury, there is risk involved in it becoming a recurring or nagging injury as his career develops.  There is a good chance that this will impact his speed and will likely relegate him to a corner OF position.  Also, like many prospects his age, Martinez still has a very raw set of offensive skills and a proneness to strike out often.


Bottom Line:  The specter of Martinez’s knee injury may cause many collectors to shy away from his cards.  But make no mistake, when healthy, Martinez’s comprehensive tool set may place him at the top of this set’s prospect list.


Carlos Rivero—Cleveland Indians SS   H/W: 6’3’’ 210 lb.   B:R  T:R   DOB: 5/20/88



Rivero is another Venezuelan free agent signee who is entering his fourth year with the Cleveland Indians organization.  Last year at Low-A Lake County, Rivero compiled his best season as a pro, hitting .261 with 7 HR 62 RBI and 26 doubles in 436 AB earning a 2008 promotion to High-A Kinston.  Rivero, despite being one of the youngest players in the Carolina League has been solid, hitting .274 with 6 HR and 57 RBI. 


Ebay Market Price: $0.60-1.00


Positives:  Rivero, despite his size, has the glove, range, and arm to play at SS at the major league level.  Some skeptics believe that he will lose some of his range as his body matures and bulks up, thus relegating him to be a slick fielding 3B.  Rivero has real power potential and above average bat speed.  The high amount of doubles this season and last are an indicator of future HR power.


Negatives:  On par with many young, physically gifted players, Rivero is unrefined at the plate and inexperienced with working counts and recognizing off-speed pitches.  While it is not a huge concern with players of Rivero’s talent, it is often the key determinant in the overall success of their development. Rivero will not set any land speed records on the basepaths, despite his apparent athletic skills.  Most concerning, however, are the observations of front office executives and personnel of Rivero’s tendencies to lose focus and become sloppy with fundamental skills.


Bottom Line:  Despite the laundry list of negatives, Rivero is young and has the ability to refine his approach to various aspects of his game.  Couple that with the untapped wealth of power potential pent up inside his 20 year old body and you have a player worth spending a few bucks on.


Zach Britton—Baltimore Orioles LHP 



Britton, a 3rd round high school pick in the 2006 draft, features a heavy 90-92 MPH fastball with a sharp slider that is improving into a plus pitch.  Mixed in with a decent curveball, Britton’s pitch repertoire has baffled hitters at Low-A Delmarva.  Britton has gone 11-7 with a 3.18 ERA this season in 26 starts. 


Ebay Market Price: $0.25-0.50


Positives:  Britton, at age 20, already has three very good major league calibur pitches and his changeup is also progressing well.  His frame has room for bulk which could add velocity to his fastball and stamina for a heavy workload. Though his 107 K’s in 141.1 IP is not dominant, he induces 3.04 groundouts per every flyout and opponents are only hitting .220 against him.  Britton seems to know how to pitch and there is always room for southpaw sinkerball pitchers in any rotation.


Negatives: Britton’s command can get away from him sometimes as he still is learning how to set up hitters and locate his array of off-speed pitches.  Also, Britton is not a big strikeout pitcher, which means that he can get hit hard from time to time when he doesn’t have his best stuff.


Bottom Line: Similar to Michael Watt, Britton has a great shot to be a mid-rotation workhorse.  The Orioles organization has strengthened itself quite a bit with strong drafts of Matt Wieters, Jake Arrieta, Brandon Snyder, and Nolan Reimold; and acquisitions of Adam Jones, Chris Tillman, Matt Albers, and Troy Patton have Baltimore positioned nicely for a bright future.



Brent Brewer—Milwaukee Brewers SS  H/W: 6’2” 190 lb.  B/T: R/R  DOB:12/19/87




How could a guy with the last name Brewer play for any other team than Milwaukee?  Certainly the Brewers were looking well beyond his last name when they selected him in the 2nd round of the 2006 draft.  Brewer showed equal flashes of brilliance and rawness last season at West Virginia where he hit .251 with 11 HR 49 RBI 42 SB and 170 K’s.  This season, Brewer began in West Virginia again and struggled hitting .213 with 0 HR and 54 K’s in 47 games.


Ebay Market Price: $0.30-0.60


Positives: Brewer’s blend of athleticism and tools is tremendous.  He has above average power potential which should develop as he adds strength to his projectible frame.  His range, arm strength, and speed are even better.  Additionally, Brewer has exuded strong leadership skills, make up, and a tireless work ethic that has prompted the Brewers organization to aggressively promote him to High A despite his early season struggles. 


Negatives: There are many rough patches surrounding this prospect.  His plate discipline and pitch recognition is still quite unrefined, though it has improved significantly since his promotion to Brevard County.  The power displayed last season has been non-existent this year as he has hit just 2 HR and Brewer’s struggles extend to the field as well where he has committed 20 errors in just 74 games since his promotion.


Bottom Line: With the presence of J.J. Hardy and Alcides Escobar looming above him, Brewer’s may find himself chasing down flyballs in Miller Park.  The Brewers would be best suited to take their foot off of the accelerator with him, allowing him to refine his plate approach and translate some of his 30-40 double power to double digit HR power.  In doing so, Brewer will be a strong candidate to be a top of the order hitter for Milwaukee in 2011.


Brandon Laird—New York Yankees 1B   H/W: 6’1” 215 lb.  B/T: R/R  DOB:9/11/87


Laird, a Scott Boras client, was selected in the 27th round of the 2007 draft and quickly displayed that he was prepared to handle professional pitching, hitting .339 with 8 HR and 29 RBI in 29 games with the Yankees’ Gulf Coast League team.  That performance earned Laird a promotion to full season Low-A Charleston where he has hit 21 HR 81 RBI and 30 doubles in 439 AB.


Ebay Market Price: $0.50-0.75


Strengths: Laird is powerfully built and knows how to use it.  He has a quick, compact swing that launches balls to all fields with tremendous power.  Unlike many other young hitters, Laird has decent plate discipline that is sure to improve as he gains more experience.  Laird has a plus arm for a 1B and is working hard to improve his physique.  Laird has good bloodlines with his brother Gerald being a solid catcher with the Texas Rangers.  Like Gerald, Brandon’s hard work outshines his natural ability.


Weaknesses: Laird’s defensive prowess has waned since high school and he profiles to be a below average fielding 1B.  Laird is not a physical specimen, and some team officials believe that he topped out in high school.  Laird will need to maintain control of his body to stay healthy and at 1B.  Though his strikeout rate is not cause for concern, his walk rate is not cause for celebration.  Laird will continue to learn to work counts, which should add to his power output down the road.


Bottom Line: The Yankees organization is thin when it comes to 1B prospects.  Laird has is by far the best hitting prospect of the bunch and has a chance to move rapidly.  Keep close tabs on his whether or not he is able to stay at 1B as he develops.  Gut instinct says that the Yankees will opt to go fishing in the free agent market for a viable 1B, but, be it as a 1B or DH, Laird will get every opportunity to work his way into the Yankees lineup within the next two to three seasons.


Joe Benson—Minnesota Twins OF   H/W: 6-2 210 lb.   B/T: R/R   DOB: 3/5/88

Minnesota’s 2006 2nd round selection who turned down a scholarship to play RB at Purdue and accepted a $575,00 contract from Twins.  Last year, Benson played his first full season last year at Low-A Beloit and had a mediocre season hitting .255 with 5 HR 38 RBI and 18 SB.  He repeated Beloit this season only to produce similar results (.247 4 HR 27 RBI 17 SB in 70 games), before suffering a stress fracture in his back that has sidelined him for the rest of the season.


Ebay Market Price: $0.50-0.75


Strengths: Benson has superb athleticism and a linebacker-like frame.  Benson’s defensive tools are even more impressive than his offensive tools, as he can play any OF position with great range and a strong arm.  Benson should have 20 HR 20 SB potential as he continues to refine his offensive approach.


Weaknesses: The back fracture is a big concern.  However, there has been speculation that he will indeed play winter ball in Hawaii or Venezuela.  If so, it would serve as an opportunity for Benson to work on his discipline at the plate and on the basepaths, which are both substandard for a player with his skill set.


Bottom Line: Benson is the consummate young athlete that is still learning to play baseball.  His game and abilities are reminiscent of a young Mark Kotsay, and if he can remain healthy and dilligent, he has all the ability to be even better than that.



This year’s list of prospects and autographs boasts a multitude of intriguing talents.  As always, prospecting is anything but an exact science, but the promise displayed in the afore mentioned talents should provide a nice bang for your prospecting buck.  Happy prospecting!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: